1. What Is Construction Arbitration?

Construction arbitration is an agreed form of private adjudication in which a neutral arbitrator—or panel—hears a dispute and issues a binding award. Most modern contracts incorporate arbitration by reference to rules published by the American Arbitration Association (AAA), JAMS, or another provider. When the contract involves interstate commerce, the proceedings fall under the Federal Arbitration Act; purely intrastate projects may invoke the Texas Arbitration Act, but in either case the award carries the same legal weight as a court judgment.

2. Why Choose Arbitration?

• Speed – Streamlined discovery and flexible scheduling cut months, sometimes years, off the litigation timeline.
• Expertise – Parties may select arbitrators with deep construction credentials, reducing the time needed to educate a jury.
• Confidentiality – Hearings and filings remain private, protecting trade secrets and business relationships.
• Finality – Awards are subject to only narrow judicial review, giving parties certainty and closure.
• Preserved Relationships – A less adversarial setting often helps the project team continue working together.

3. Step-by-Step Arbitration Road-Map

1. Arbitration Clause
   The contract designates arbitration and adopts governing rules. Pay careful attention to venue, governing law, and any dollar limits on consolidated claims.
2. Notice & Filing
   A party files a demand outlining the dispute and requested relief. The respondent answers and may assert counterclaims.
3. Selection of Arbitrator(s)
   Single arbitrator for smaller matters; three-member panel for complex or high-value disputes. Credentials, impartiality, and availability are critical.
4. Preliminary Conference
   The arbitrator sets the procedural calendar: pleadings, discovery limits, motion practice, hearing dates, and pre-hearing disclosures.
5. Discovery & Motion Practice
   Discovery is narrower than in litigation—often limited to targeted document exchanges and a handful of depositions. Dispositive motions are permitted but sparingly granted.
6. Hearing
   Conducted much like a bench trial but with relaxed evidentiary rules. Witnesses testify, experts offer opinions, and exhibits are admitted in an organized, technology-friendly setting.
7. Award
   The arbitrator deliberates and issues a written award, typically within 30 days. The award explains the decision, allocates damages, fees, and interest, and may order specific performance.
8. Confirmation & Enforcement
   Unless the losing party voluntarily pays, the prevailing party files a short petition in state or federal district court to convert the award into a judgment. Vacatur or modification is available only for serious procedural or ethical defects.

4. Potential Drawbacks

• Limited Appeal – Courts can set aside an award only for fraud, evident partiality, or similar fundamental flaws.
• Front-Loaded Costs – Arbitrator compensation and administrative fees can be substantial, especially with a three-person panel.
• No Formal Precedent – Awards are not published, providing little guidance for future disputes.

5. Best Practices for a Smooth Arbitration

Drafting the Clause

• Define the governing rules and forum clearly.
• Specify the number and qualifications of arbitrators.
• Address consolidation or joinder of subcontractor disputes to avoid parallel proceedings.

Preparing the Case

• Preserve project documents in real time; arbitration moves too quickly to reconstruct the record later.
• Retain experts early to frame technical issues and damages.
• Use the preliminary conference to tailor discovery limits to the dispute’s size and complexity.

Conducting the Hearing

• Streamline witness lists and exhibits to keep the focus on pivotal facts.
• Present complex schedules or cost data through graphics and summaries that an industry-savvy arbitrator will appreciate.

Post-Award

• Calendar the deadline for confirmation to guard against belated challenges.
• Evaluate whether interest and attorney’s fees are recoverable under the contract or governing statute before filing for enforcement.

Connect With Us

Arbitration, when properly planned and managed, delivers swift, knowledgeable, and enforceable resolutions to construction disputes without the public spectacle of a courtroom battle. By drafting precise arbitration clauses, selecting seasoned neutrals, and approaching the process with disciplined preparation, contractors and owners can protect their schedules, budgets, and business relationships while keeping control of how—and where—their disputes are decided.

‍